What Is Your Favorite Girl Scout Cookie?

[sass_in_the_pants]

Cuz um I just ate most of a box of Do-si-dos.

I don't know how to do that thing where you can pick from a list, so here are your options:

-Thin Mints

-Do-si-dos

-Trefoils

-Tagalongs

-Samoas

-Thanks-A-Lot

-Lemon Chalet Cremes

-Are they made with real girl scouts?

[Msterbeau]

I don't like Girl Scout cookies. There. I said it.

[nilhil_glory]

i only like them when they are made from real girl scouts

[Destroit]

Thin mints, that goes with Raven too.

The ones made with 100% Girl Scout leave this weird metallic sort of aftertaste. Definately not for me.

[nilhil_glory]

The ones made with 100% Girl Scout leave this weird metallic sort of aftertaste. Definately not for me.

hmm i wonder where you pick your girl scouts from?

[phee]

I like the peanut butter patties...

[TygerLili]

I'm not a fan of any cookies that aren't fresh out of the oven; if I have to pick something to be a good samaritan I'll go with Thin Mints.

[Rayne]

I like the peanut butter patties...

Those are Tagalongs.

That said, I like them all ... We've got tons this year since my Mom went wild and bought a million boxes. I have half a case at my house and more where those came from.

[pharoh]

tagalongs and whatever the coconut/chocolate ones are......

they are all the devil

[Gaf The Horse With Tears]

Tagalongs.. but I rarely buy cookies... fresh baked is where it's at.

[Rayne]

whatever the coconut/chocolate ones are......

Samoa's. I opened myself a box of those a few days ago.

[TomCat]

Samoa's. I opened myself a box of those a few days ago.

Yup, Samoas. Hands down.

[Rayne]

Pharoh just made me go get a Samoa ....

And I brought an unopened box of Thin Mints back to my desk with me ....

[TomCat]

Quit teasin'...I gotta fit into a suit for a wedding soon...damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn

[Rayne]

Cuz um I just ate most of a box of Do-si-dos.

I don't know how to do that thing where you can pick from a list, so here are your options:

-Thin Mints

-Do-si-dos

-Trefoils

-Tagalongs

-Samoas

-Thanks-A-Lot

-Lemon Chalet Cremes

-Are they made with real girl scouts?

I have All-Abouts at my house .... I bribe the kids with those.

[Rayne]

Quit teasin'...I gotta fit into a suit for a wedding soon...damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn

I should be trying to drop some of my weight ... no add to it.

But no such luck at Girl Scout Cookie time.

[CandyQuackenbush]

I was a girl scout from 1990-1998.

I am so sick and tired of those damn thing. Esp. when they changed all the names except thin mints.

I remember when I would go door to door, and they where $1.50 a box, and thats when they weren't these little "donate to charity" pieces that they are now.

[GOREgeouslyDecorated]

Samoas all the way - I could LIVE off those!

[jadnifer]

Tagalongs are my utmost favortie. Samoas come in at a VERY close second.

Never tried the ones that are made from real Girl Scouts though. Are they any good?

[punk_princess]

Samoas

I ordered 4 boxes from my niece.

[Bernadette]

Those lemon ones are tasty. I also like the shortbread kind... thin mints are probably my least favorite.

A little sidebar -- my cubemate at work at a whole sleeve of the mints, and had to go home sick about an hour later?!

[Jadis]

frozen samoas are sooo good. they're the ones with the coconut and chocolate.... yummy goodness.

[TomCat]

frozen samoas are sooo good. they're the ones with the coconut and chocolate.... yummy goodness.

Oh yeah, that's how we do it too. Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

[freydis]

The peanut butter ones.

[Fierce Critter]

Tagalongs.

But they're overpriced. $3.50 a box is ridiculous. That said, one of the nice things about an improved household income is that I was able to buy some of those overpriced cookies the other day.

Jon loves the thin mints.

I like the lemon creams. But does anyone else remember that for a very brief season or two, they had a different lemon cookie that was delicious? The chalet creams aren't as good, but they'll do with a cup of tea to dunk them in.