Star Wars vs. LOTR

[phee]

Middle Earth vs The Deathstar

Orcs vs Storm Troopers

Hobits vs Ewoks

Jedi vs Rangers

Which one did you enjoy more?

[SeraphBastille]

I love the Star Wars universe...but Tolkien wins as a story teller

[Gaf The Horse With Tears]

I am so god damn sick of both of them...

[Guest Megalicious]

To quote Randal, "All right look, there's only one return, okay, and it ain't "of the King," it's "of the Jedi."

Though I do love Tolkien, very much.

[phee]

Can we vote for Kieślowski's Three Colors trilogy instead?

Well we could....

I liked "White" myself... Revenge is friggen awesome

[Destroit]

I know I will get many "WTF!?!?!"s by this answer but,

I've never seen either. I saw the first three original Star Wars movies EONS ago when I was a kid. Jabba rulez, that's what stood out to me when I was a kid. I do remember the movies though. I've also played the video games and have picked up on quite a bit of Star Warsism just from that.

As for LOTR...everyone in my family is obsessed with it. My Boshy has been reading the same three LOTR books for like 10 years now, since I bought her a new set of them when I was 12 (her other ones, I believe were pretty hit). So I've never seen the movies but pretty much have the grasp of what it's about.

So with all that said, I will pick Star Wars FTW. I liked the story better and I'm always more of a futuristic sci-fi person than an olden days D&D kinda person anyday.

[Gaf The Horse With Tears]

I have to add.. Until there is something like The Silmarillion for Star Wars... I'm going to have to lean toward LOTR.

[Simon Bar Sinister]

LOTR, hands fucking down.

[GothicRavenGoddess (3)]

LOTR, hands fucking down.

yeah I have to agree.

[n0Mad]

When The Matrix came out, I thought those movies would be the greatest trilogy of all times. Then Reloaded came out and ruined that idea and Revolutions buried it in the ground.

[phee]

When The Matrix came out, I thought those movies would be the greatest trilogy of all times. Then Reloaded came out and ruined that idea and Revolutions buried it in the ground.

Indeed

[Goth Brooks]

Warhammer

[phee]

We have a tie so far

[Rev.Reverence]

..ILUMINATUS TRILOGY...

[Rev.Reverence]

We have a tie so far

I can not chose between them...I am..un-dork-sided..

[Troy Spiral (13)]

I generally prefer sci fi to fantasy, but LOTR just has way too much class. I'll generally have to pick class over fun-romp when it comes to "votes". If we were just talking about going to see a flick or hanging out that'd be different. (tie broken at this point ) Not that I don't like star wars, definitely like star wars. It has a sort of apples to oranges feel to me to try and pick between the two.

[Msterbeau]

As much as I watch Star Wars, especially with the girls, LOTR is the better movie experience overall...

[StormKnight (1)]

I generally prefer sci fi to fantasy, but LOTR just has way too much class. I'll generally have to pick class over fun-romp when it comes to "votes". If we were just talking about going to see a flick or hanging out that'd be different. (tie broken at this point ) Not that I don't like star wars, definitely like star wars. It has a sort of apples to oranges feel to me to try and pick between the two.

+1

[phee]

LOTR jumps into the lead!!!